Lindsey Fay REALTOR®License #: 9552794

Lindsey Fay REALTOR®License #: 9552794

About Lindsey Fay, REALTOR®

Back to Search

Lindsey Fay


License #: 9552794



Lindsey is a Real Estate Advisor at Rutledge Properties.


Lindsey's keen intelligence and comprehensive understanding of the greater Boston real estate market makes her a very strong asset to her clients. Since 2016, Lindsey has helped her clients successfully navigate the home selling and buying process. She is especially sensitive to the needs of families relocating to the area and with her vast knowledge of various neighborhoods, area schools, and local resources, she can help make the transition into the area seamless. Lindsey also has considerable savvy when it comes to home renovation projects and the best ways to present a home to the market. All this, coupled with her warmth, good humor, and grace sets her apart and makes the experience of working with her a pleasure.


Prior to real estate, Lindsey worked in executive recruiting. She grew up in Westwood MA and Wellesley MA and attended the Noble & Greenough School in Dedham and Trinity College in Connecticut. She and her husband currently live in Wellesley with their three children and two rescue golden retrievers- Wrigley and Memphis. When Lindsey is not selling real estate, you can find her supporting local youth athletics. She is also active in the Wellesley Public Schools.


"I could not have asked for a better real estate agent. Lindsey made the entire process seem effortless and explained everything in a way that was easy to understand. She was thorough, professional, and so easy to work with. It’s obvious Lindsey cares about her clients and I feel lucky to have worked with her."
"Lindsey was so unbelievably helpful in the search for our perfect home. After only a few visits with her, she knew exactly what we were looking for. She was able to see our vision and eventually led us to our dream home! Lindsey is extremely personable, responsive, and always one step ahead of the game. We couldn't recommend her more and we will be using her again in the future!"
"Lindsey has proven herself to be more than capable.  In addition to knowing everything about the Boston metro-west home market, she's energetic and upbeat, extremely detail oriented (and always quick to respond), and business savvy without being snooty (as many brokers unfortunately seem to be... !).  She was always upfront with fair numbers, advising us on the best, real potential options for our budget. Finally, as a mom with young kids, I was especially grateful that Lindsey also has a family and offered so much personal insight into various pros and cons when considering homes to raise our kids in.  We are so happy in our homes and would recommend her with a million stars if we could!!"


Area Covered: Wellesley, Weston, Needham, Dover, Natick

Contact Me

Rutledge Propertiesindependently owned & operated

572 Washington St,

Have Questions?